Bankruptcy vs. Consumer Proposal: The Impact on Tax Refunds

  1. Home
  2.  » 
  3. Bankruptcy
  4.  » Bankruptcy vs. Consumer Proposal: The Impact on Tax Refunds

Navigating the path toward financial stability involves making informed decisions, and two significant options to consider are bankruptcy and consumer proposals. Both avenues provide a way out of debt and offer distinct asset management approaches. When it comes to tax refunds, a crucial aspect of your financial picture, understanding how bankruptcy and consumer proposals handle them is essential.

Exploring Tax Refunds in Different Scenarios

Tax Refunds in Bankruptcy

In the context of bankruptcy in Canada, a tax refund is categorized as an asset. This means that any expected tax refund for the year you filed for bankruptcy will no longer be applicable. Furthermore, your trustee will also gain control over any tax refunds owed to you from previous years.

An important note is that if you filed an amended return or claimed a disability tax credit for prior years, you won’t receive any refunds, even after your bankruptcy is finalized. Individuals sometimes become eligible for a disability tax credit after bankruptcy discharge. If you are entitled to a refund from the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA), it will be sent to the trustee for years before the bankruptcy and directly to you for years following the bankruptcy.

Tax Refunds in a Consumer Proposal

Consumer proposals present a different approach when it comes to tax refunds. One of the key advantages of opting for a consumer proposal is that you retain ownership of all your assets, including any potential income tax refund. If you have no outstanding tax debts from previous years and choose the consumer proposal route, your tax refunds remain unaffected.

For instance, if you rely on your tax refund to cover specific expenses like summer camp or car insurance, filing a consumer proposal might be an intelligent choice. It’s worth noting that the scenario becomes more complex if you owe taxes to the CRA from prior years. In such cases, the CRA’s stance is that any refunds related to income earned before filing the consumer proposal will be used to offset your debts to them.

Managing Tax Returns in a Consumer Proposal

The responsibility of handling tax returns differs between bankruptcy and consumer proposals. In a bankruptcy scenario, the trustee is responsible for filing your income tax return for the year of bankruptcy and any outstanding back taxes. Any refunds owed to you will be collected by the trustee and distributed among your unsecured creditors.

When opting for a consumer proposal, you are required to submit all tax returns. Your previous tax returns must be filed to gain approval for a consumer proposal. Additionally, the CRA may request your commitment to timely filing future paperwork and prompt payment of taxes.

Navigating Tax Debts in the Era of CERB

In the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic and the Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB) introduction, understanding the implications of tax debts has become increasingly vital for individuals seeking to secure their financial well-being.

What is CERB?

The Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB) was a temporary financial assistance program introduced by the Canadian government in response to the economic challenges posed by the COVID-19 pandemic. The CERB provided financial support to individuals who lost their jobs, could not work, or had their income significantly reduced due to the pandemic.

The program aimed to help Canadian citizens and residents directly impacted by the pandemic-related economic shutdowns, enabling them to cover essential expenses such as food, housing, and other necessities. Recipients of the CERB received regular payments over a defined period to help them navigate the financial hardships caused by the pandemic.

It’s important to note that the CERB was a time-limited program and was replaced by other measures as the pandemic situation evolved. The program’s specifics, including eligibility criteria, payment amounts, and duration, were subject to government decisions and may have changed over time.

What is CRB?

The Canada Recovery Benefit (CRB) is a financial assistance program introduced by the Canadian government to provide support to individuals who are facing income loss or reduced earnings due to various reasons, including the ongoing impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic. The CRB is designed to assist those not eligible for traditional employment insurance benefits.

Similar to the Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB), introduced earlier in response to the pandemic, the CRB offers financial aid to self-employed individuals, gig workers, contract workers, or those who have experienced other forms of income disruption. It aims to provide temporary financial relief to those unable to work due to reasons related to the pandemic, such as illness, caregiving responsibilities, or reduced work hours.

How Do These Measures Impact Bankruptcy In Canada?

Recent developments have altered the landscape, particularly concerning CERB overpayments and their impact on Canadian bankruptcies. Many individuals received CERB and CRB payments during the pandemic without adequate tax withholding. This resulted in instances where taxpayers found themselves with unforeseen tax bills.

If you owe taxes due to increased taxable income and insufficient withholding or received a non-certification notice from the CERB’s collection agency, a tax liability might emerge unexpectedly. However, as long as there’s no fraudulent activity involved, a consumer proposal can resolve CRA debts, even encompassing obligations for additional tax payments if your income justifies it.

Seeking Expert Guidance

To gain a comprehensive understanding of how your tax refund would be influenced by bankruptcy or a consumer proposal, it’s advisable to engage in a discussion with a knowledgeable trustee. They can provide personalized insights based on your unique circumstances. Contact us today for a free consultation to empower you with the information needed to make informed financial decisions. Your journey towards financial stability starts with informed choices, and we’re here to guide you every step of the way.

× How can I help you?